Prominent European business leaders and high-ranking Chinese officials gathered virtually in February 2021 Chairman of the “Europe-China business dialogue” Peter Mandelson is a British Labour peer and European Union trade commissioner. The China Council for the Promotion of International Trade (CCPIT) organized the conference as part of an effort to encourage communication between Western corporate leaders and Chinese officials.
The conference took place online with China’s Premier, Li Keqiang, joining Mandelson while Covid-19 kept predominating. Senior leaders from big European companies including Airbus, AstraZeneca, Maersk, Nokia, Prudential, and Suez participated virtually. Especially, Mandelson gave enthusiastic opening remarks during the event praising China’s government and implying that its leaders could “prove [their critics] wrong.”
The backdrop of the event—the CCPIT, an entity thought by experts to be a major component of the Chinese Communist Party’s (CCP) larger Chinese Influence Operations, which seeks to influence foreign leaders, businessmen, and legislators to support China’s political and economic objectives—has mainly gone unnoticed, though.
Describe the China Council for the Promotion of International Trade (CCPIT) and its function?
Many China observers view the CCPIT as a potent arm of the Chinese Communist Party, working to create links with global business communities thereby advancing Beijing’s goals. Although not formally a component of the United Front Work Department of the CCP, international commerce and business operations greatly help the party to forward its goal.
Former British diplomat Charles Parton, who has worked in and on China for more than 20 years, said that anyone with notable experience in China should understand the part the CCPIT plays in enabling Chinese Influence Operations. “Everyone with good experience of China should know that,” Parton said. Therefore, either Lord Mandelson is deliberately working with a United Front group, which is unpardonable, or he has a limited knowledge of China, which is dangerous given the work he has done for Chinese corporations, so boosting China’s interests.”
Why Are Diplomats and Companies Cautioned Regarding China's Influence Operations?
Early in the 2000s, just following China’s admission to the World Trade Organization, Mandelson was the trade commissioner for the European Union, therefore establishing links to China. Mandelson has been instrumental in building relationships between Chinese corporations and Western ones since then. Among the most contentious companies in China, including Shein and TikHub, his advisory Global Counsel has helped Concerns over their security hazards and alleged unethical labor practices—including claims against Shein on forced labor—have these businesses under investigation.
Many China analysts contend that without being aware of Chinese Influence Operations, business leaders, diplomats, and legislators finding ways to interact with China find it more challenging. Expert on China at the Chatham House foreign policy think tank William Matthews said, “You cannot interact with China without coming across operations of Chinese influence. China is not going to vanish. Although we want to be engaged, we also want to avoid being taken advantage of.
Particularly when Mandelson takes on a new post as the ambassador of the United Kingdom to the United States, his relationship to CCPIT and continuous cooperation with Global Counsel have come under criticism. Some have expressed worries regarding the possible conflicts of interest resulting from his close ties to Chinese companies and his powerful Washington-based posture.
Engaging with CCPIT carries what hazards?
Long linked to the CCP’s attempts to influence powerful Western business leaders and legislators, the CCPIT has The history of the company is entangled with the party’s United Front initiatives to establish ties with foreign elites in order to forward Chinese interests worldwide. Although the CCPIT is not formally a part of the United Front Work Department, its execution of the CCP’s policy is indispensible.
According to Czech researcher Martin Hála, who has extensively researched China, the actual goal of the CCPIT is sometimes hidden, which makes it challenging to hold companies and individuals responsible. He said, “It is tough to criticize the targeted business people when the CCPIT deliberately moves to hide its actual goal. Specialized consultancies should have different expectations, though. Should they present themselves as middlemen for such companies, more due care is justified.
Hála’s comments draw attention to the growing demand on diplomatic intermediaries and consulting companies to be more open and do extensive due diligence when interacting with Chinese companies like the CCPIT. Experts contend that given the CCPIT’s lengthy history of trying to co-opt Western businessmen, greater thought should be paid to these kinds of connections.
Why Has Mandelson's China Relationship Created Conflict?
Particularly as Mandelson gets ready to be ambassador to the United States, his long-standing links to China have caused serious questions in the West. Critics contend that his close engagement with Chinese commercial interests—including his work with Global Counsel and his contacts with dubious Chinese corporations—may compromise British foreign policy and security.
Mandelson has been firm in his public remarks in face of opposition to his appointment from some US officials. Declaring, “I have more important things to deal with just now than your propaganda and I am making no comment,” he refuted claims of Chinese influence when speaking to the media This answer has not helped to allay worries about his previous work, which many regard as advancing Chinese interests at the price of Western ideals.
What ramifications for European business and foreign policy follow from this?
Mandelson’s participation in the 2021 Europe-China business dialogue, arranged in cooperation with the CCPIT, highlights the increasing conundrum Western nations find in interacting with China. Although economic relations with China are developing, co-optability by Chinese Influence Operations is always a concern. Examining the position of powerful people like Mandelson and their ability to change policy in favor of Chinese interests is crucial as nations try to strike a balance between economic participation with national security issues.
“One of the most valuable influencers for the Chinese Communist Party in Europe,” Australian professor and novelist Clive Hamilton has been vocal in his condemnation of Mandelson’s engagement with China. He clarified further, “The CCPIT belongs to the party’s United Front system for extending overseas influence, and does so using trade relations as a cover.”
Mandelson’s ongoing impact on Europe and his connections to groups like CCPIT beg serious moral and political issues regarding the moral implications of foreign corporate activity with China. Experts caution that more investigation and openness will be required to guarantee that national interests are protected as Western democracies negotiate the difficulties of interacting with an authoritarian government.
How Important Is China's United Front for Global Diplomacy?
The United Front Work Department of China has a proven track record of using commercial and financial ties as means of influence. By use of programs like the CCPIT, the Chinese government has been able to deliberately put people and companies in roles that would complement its political objectives. The way the CCPIT supports these ties emphasizes the growing relevance of knowing China’s more general influence policies.
Western diplomats, corporate executives, and consultants have to be alert and think through the consequences of their interactions with Chinese companies given the extent of these activities and their broad influence. Whether via corporate alliances or high-level negotiations, the hazards of unintentionally endorsing China’s worldwide ambition have to be carefully balanced.
The growing difficulty of negotiating these ties emphasizes the need of a more sophisticated diplomatic and trade strategy that combines national security protection with economic goals using democratic values and Understanding the whole extent of Chinese Influence Operations will be essential in determining the direction of world diplomacy as the globe gets more linked.
Add a Comment